Evolution and Natural Selection: NMAT Biology Review
Introduction to Evolution
Evolution is one of the central unifying concepts in biology. It explains both the diversity of life on Earth and the similarities shared among all living organisms. In its simplest definition, evolution refers to the change in the genetic composition of populations over successive generations. These changes occur through mechanisms such as mutation, natural selection, genetic drift, and gene flow.
For the NMAT Biology section, understanding evolution is crucial because it integrates genetics, ecology, physiology, and molecular biology. Questions often focus on how evolutionary processes operate, the evidence supporting evolution, and the role of natural selection in shaping organisms’ adaptations.
Historical Development of Evolutionary Theory
The idea that species change over time existed long before Charles Darwin. Early thinkers such as Jean-Baptiste Lamarck proposed that organisms could acquire traits during their lifetime and pass them to offspring (inheritance of acquired characteristics). Although Lamarck’s mechanism was incorrect, his emphasis on adaptation and environmental influence was important.
The modern theory of evolution was firmly established by Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace in the mid-19th century. Darwin’s landmark work, On the Origin of Species (1859), introduced the concept of natural selection as the primary mechanism driving evolution. Darwin proposed that individuals within populations vary, some of these variations are heritable, and individuals with advantageous traits are more likely to survive and reproduce.
Key Principles of Natural Selection
Natural selection operates based on several fundamental principles:
-
Variation – Individuals within a population differ in traits such as size, color, physiology, and behavior.
-
Heritability – Some variations are genetically inherited from parents to offspring.
-
Overproduction – Organisms produce more offspring than the environment can support.
-
Differential Survival and Reproduction – Individuals with traits that improve survival or reproduction are more likely to pass those traits to the next generation.
Over time, advantageous traits become more common in the population, leading to adaptation. Natural selection does not work toward a goal; it simply favors traits that are beneficial under specific environmental conditions.
Sources of Genetic Variation
Evolution depends on genetic variation, which arises from several sources:
Mutation
Mutations are random changes in DNA sequences. They may occur due to errors during DNA replication or exposure to mutagens such as radiation or chemicals. Most mutations are neutral or harmful, but some can provide beneficial traits that enhance survival or reproduction.
Genetic Recombination
During sexual reproduction, processes such as crossing over and independent assortment create new combinations of alleles. This increases genetic diversity within populations, providing raw material for natural selection.
Gene Flow
Gene flow occurs when individuals migrate between populations, introducing new alleles. This can increase genetic variation within a population or reduce differences between populations.
Types of Natural Selection
Natural selection can take different forms depending on environmental conditions:
Directional Selection
Directional selection favors one extreme phenotype over others. This often occurs when environmental conditions change, such as increased pollution or climate shifts. A classic example is the evolution of antibiotic resistance in bacteria.
Stabilizing Selection
Stabilizing selection favors intermediate phenotypes and eliminates extreme variations. This type of selection maintains the status quo and reduces variation. Human birth weight is a common example, where extremely low or high weights are selected against.
Disruptive Selection
Disruptive selection favors individuals at both extremes of a trait distribution, potentially leading to speciation. This can occur when different ecological niches exist within the same environment.
Fitness and Adaptation
In evolutionary biology, fitness refers to an organism’s ability to survive and reproduce in its environment. Fitness is not about physical strength but about reproductive success. An adaptation is a heritable trait that increases fitness.
Adaptations can be:
-
Structural, such as camouflage or specialized limbs
-
Physiological, such as toxin resistance
-
Behavioral, such as mating rituals or migration patterns
It is important to note that adaptations are context-dependent. A trait that is beneficial in one environment may be disadvantageous in another.
Sexual Selection
Sexual selection is a special form of natural selection that arises from differences in mating success. It can result in traits that improve mating opportunities rather than survival.
Intrasexual Selection
This involves competition among individuals of the same sex, such as male-male competition for mates.
Intersexual Selection
This occurs when individuals of one sex prefer certain traits in mates, such as elaborate plumage or displays.
Sexual selection can lead to extreme traits that may seem maladaptive from a survival perspective but persist because they enhance reproductive success.
Genetic Drift
Unlike natural selection, genetic drift is a random process that changes allele frequencies, especially in small populations. It does not favor adaptive traits.
Bottleneck Effect
A bottleneck occurs when a population is drastically reduced due to a natural disaster or human activity. The surviving population may have limited genetic diversity.
Founder Effect
The founder effect occurs when a small group of individuals establishes a new population. The genetic makeup of the new population may differ significantly from the original population.
Genetic drift can lead to the loss of alleles and reduced genetic variation, making populations more vulnerable to environmental changes.
Speciation
Speciation is the process by which new species arise. It occurs when populations become reproductively isolated and accumulate genetic differences over time.
Allopatric Speciation
Allopatric speciation occurs when populations are geographically separated, such as by mountains or bodies of water. Over time, genetic divergence leads to reproductive isolation.
Sympatric Speciation
Sympatric speciation occurs without geographic separation, often due to ecological specialization or polyploidy in plants.
Reproductive Isolation
Reproductive isolation mechanisms prevent interbreeding and can be:
-
Prezygotic, such as differences in mating behavior or timing
-
Postzygotic, such as hybrid inviability or sterility
Evidence for Evolution
Multiple lines of evidence support the theory of evolution:
Fossil Record
Fossils provide historical evidence of extinct species and transitional forms, showing changes over time.
Comparative Anatomy
Homologous structures, such as vertebrate forelimbs, indicate common ancestry. Analogous structures demonstrate convergent evolution.
Molecular Biology
DNA and protein sequence comparisons reveal genetic similarities among species, providing strong evidence for evolutionary relationships.
Biogeography
The geographic distribution of species supports evolution, especially patterns seen on islands and isolated regions.
Evolution in Action
Evolution is not just a historical process; it can be observed in real time. Examples include:
-
Antibiotic resistance in bacteria
-
Pesticide resistance in insects
-
Rapid evolution of viruses
These examples are particularly relevant for NMAT questions that connect evolution to medicine and public health.
Common Misconceptions About Evolution
Several misconceptions frequently appear in exam questions:
-
Individuals do not evolve; populations do.
-
Evolution does not aim for perfection.
-
Natural selection works on existing variation, not need.
-
Evolution and natural selection are not synonymous; natural selection is one mechanism of evolution.
Understanding these distinctions is critical for avoiding common traps in multiple-choice questions.
Importance of Evolution in Medicine
Evolutionary principles are essential in medicine. The emergence of drug-resistant pathogens, cancer evolution within the body, and genetic diseases all involve evolutionary processes. For NMAT examinees, this connection highlights why evolution is not just theoretical but highly practical.
Summary
Evolution explains how life changes over time through genetic variation and differential reproduction. Natural selection is the primary mechanism driving adaptive evolution, while processes such as mutation, genetic drift, and gene flow also shape populations. Speciation leads to biodiversity, and multiple lines of evidence strongly support evolutionary theory. A solid understanding of evolution and natural selection is essential for mastering NMAT Biology and for future medical studies.
Problem Sets: Evolution and Natural Selection
Questions 1–5: Basic Concepts
Q1. Which of the following best defines evolution?
A. Changes in traits within an individual during its lifetime
B. Changes in allele frequencies within a population over generations
C. The origin of life from non-living matter
D. Adaptation of organisms to their environment without genetic change
Q2. Which condition is essential for natural selection to occur?
A. Random mating
B. High mutation rate
C. Heritable variation among individuals
D. Small population size
Q3. Natural selection acts directly on:
A. Genes
B. Genotypes
C. Phenotypes
D. Chromosomes
Q4. Which statement about fitness is CORRECT?
A. Fitness refers to physical strength
B. Fitness is measured by lifespan alone
C. Fitness refers to reproductive success
D. Fitness is the same for all individuals in a species
Q5. Which of the following is NOT a source of genetic variation?
A. Mutation
B. Genetic recombination
C. Gene flow
D. Natural selection
Questions 6–10: Types of Selection
Q6. A population of insects shifts toward darker coloration due to industrial pollution. This is an example of:
A. Stabilizing selection
B. Disruptive selection
C. Directional selection
D. Sexual selection
Q7. Which type of selection reduces variation by favoring intermediate phenotypes?
A. Directional
B. Stabilizing
C. Disruptive
D. Balancing
Q8. Disruptive selection can potentially lead to:
A. Extinction
B. Reduced genetic variation
C. Speciation
D. Genetic drift
Q9. Sexual selection differs from natural selection because it primarily favors traits that:
A. Increase survival
B. Improve mating success
C. Reduce mutation rates
D. Increase genetic stability
Q10. Which example best illustrates intrasexual selection?
A. Female birds choosing colorful males
B. Male deer competing for mates
C. Camouflage in prey species
D. Antibiotic resistance in bacteria
Questions 11–15: Genetic Drift and Gene Flow
Q11. Genetic drift has the greatest effect in populations that are:
A. Large and stable
B. Small and isolated
C. Large and diverse
D. Constantly migrating
Q12. The founder effect occurs when:
A. A population is reduced by a natural disaster
B. New alleles enter a population through migration
C. A small group establishes a new population
D. Natural selection favors extreme phenotypes
Q13. Which process tends to reduce genetic differences between populations?
A. Mutation
B. Genetic drift
C. Natural selection
D. Gene flow
Q14. Unlike natural selection, genetic drift:
A. Depends on environmental conditions
B. Is always adaptive
C. Occurs randomly
D. Increases fitness
Q15. Which scenario best represents a bottleneck effect?
A. Migration between populations
B. Rapid increase in population size
C. Severe population reduction due to a disaster
D. Long-term directional selection
Questions 16–20: Speciation and Evidence of Evolution
Q16. Allopatric speciation occurs primarily due to:
A. Behavioral isolation
B. Geographic separation
C. Polyploidy
D. Sexual selection
Q17. Which of the following is a prezygotic reproductive isolating mechanism?
A. Hybrid sterility
B. Hybrid inviability
C. Different mating seasons
D. Reduced hybrid fitness
Q18. Homologous structures provide evidence for:
A. Convergent evolution
B. Common ancestry
C. Genetic drift
D. Mutation
Q19. Which evidence for evolution is based on DNA and protein comparisons?
A. Fossil record
B. Biogeography
C. Comparative anatomy
D. Molecular biology
Q20. The rapid evolution of antibiotic resistance in bacteria demonstrates:
A. Lamarckian inheritance
B. Evolution in individuals
C. Natural selection acting on variation
D. Genetic drift in large populations
Answer Keys with Explanations
Q1. B
Evolution is defined as changes in allele frequencies within populations over generations.
Q2. C
Without heritable variation, natural selection cannot occur.
Q3. C
Natural selection acts on phenotypes, though evolution occurs at the genetic level.
Q4. C
Fitness refers to reproductive success, not strength or lifespan alone.
Q5. D
Natural selection does not create variation; it acts on existing variation.
Q6. C
Directional selection favors one extreme phenotype.
Q7. B
Stabilizing selection favors intermediate phenotypes and reduces variation.
Q8. C
Disruptive selection can split populations and promote speciation.
Q9. B
Sexual selection increases mating success, not necessarily survival.
Q10. B
Intrasexual selection involves competition among individuals of the same sex.
Q11. B
Genetic drift has stronger effects in small, isolated populations.
Q12. C
The founder effect occurs when a small group starts a new population.
Q13. D
Gene flow introduces alleles between populations, reducing differences.
Q14. C
Genetic drift is random and not adaptive.
Q15. C
A bottleneck involves a drastic reduction in population size.
Q16. B
Allopatric speciation results from geographic isolation.
Q17. C
Different mating seasons prevent fertilization, making this prezygotic.
Q18. B
Homologous structures indicate common ancestry.
Q19. D
Molecular biology uses DNA and protein comparisons as evidence.
Q20. C
Antibiotic resistance shows natural selection acting on existing variation.
